[seqfan] The Demichel errors, continued

N. J. A. Sloane njas at research.att.com
Sat Dec 17 20:39:01 CET 2011


Dear Seq Fans, 
Richard Mathar and I have been looking into the problem.
One clue is that sequences involving cosec(x) are often (alays?)
wrong.

Suppose back in 1996 there was a bug in the csc function.
I looked for the first cosec in his list (see a013538,txt), and it is here:

%I A012854
%S A012854 1,0,0,55,7,38,219,1487,11570,101682,995254,1814866833,126624718,
%T A012854 1619876114,22344623929,95542242048111,5222279193717,87722551872998,
%U A012854 1561364880901471,29353667049630175,581233980566953138
%V A012854 -1,0,-0,55,-7,38,-219,1487,-11570,101682,-995254,1814866833,
%W A012854 -126624718,1619876114,-22344623929,95542242048111,-5222279193717,
%X A012854 87722551872998,-1561364880901471,29353667049630175
%N A012854 log(cosec(x)*log(x+1))=-x+55/4!*x^4-7/5!*x^5+38/6!*x^6-219/7!*x^7...
%R A012854
%O A012854 0,4
%K A012854 sign,done
%A A012854 Patrick DEMICHEL (dml at hpfrcu03.france.hp.com)

Sure enough, this is wrong!

If we assume the log parts of log(cosec(x)*log(x+1)) are correct,
then this says that - if my calculations are correct -  that
the bad-cosec function is 

series(1*x^(-1)-1/2-1/12*x+5/24*x^2+1541/720*x^3-1601/1440*x^4-10187/60480*x^5+18337/
40320*x^6+1186291/518400*x^7-1793257/1451520*x^8-11568989/68428800*x^9+475543283/
958003200*x^10+14112561699877/2615348736000*x^11-375261235627/134120448000*x^12-\
106979176397/251073478656*x^13+14384882695861/12553673932800*x^14+39233031299960999/
2910169866240000*x^15-63754358387747431/9146248151040000*x^16-54613060385569779241/
51090942171709440000*x^17+19469639890894136927/6812125622894592000*x^18+O(x^19),x,19)

or in other words (I don't know is this will work in email)

       -1                        2   1541  3   1601  4   10187  5   18337  6   1186291  7
s5 := x   - 1/2 - 1/12 x + 5/24 x  + ---- x  - ---- x  - ----- x  + ----- x  + ------- x
                                     720       1440      60480      40320      518400

       1793257  8   11568989  9   475543283  10   14112561699877  11   375261235627  12
     - ------- x  - -------- x  + --------- x   + -------------- x   - ------------ x
       1451520      68428800      958003200       2615348736000        134120448000

       106979176397  13   14384882695861  14   39233031299960999  15   63754358387747431
     - ------------ x   + -------------- x   + ----------------- x   - -----------------
       251073478656       12553673932800       2910169866240000        9146248151040000

     16   54613060385569779241  17   19469639890894136927  18      19
    x   - -------------------- x   + -------------------- x   + O(x  )
          51090942171709440000       6812125622894592000


Unfortunately this does not explain the other errors.
For example,
%I A012856
%S A012856 6,40,1197,888,6945664,976514838,836054516,47528446559105,
%T A012856 15241280332373681,13709908797232583,2906353877902946339671,
%U A012856 2663198791987064856806,1535992958057301680879410
%N A012856 log(cosec(x)*arcsin(x))=6/2!*x^2+40/4!*x^4+1197/6!*x^6+888/8!*x^8...
%R A012856
%O A012856 0,1
%K A012856 nonn
%A A012856 Patrick DEMICHEL (dml at hpfrcu03.france.hp.com)

is still wrong, even if we replace cosec by bad-cosec.

Yet this one is correct:
%I A012063
%S A012063 1,1,1,3,9,49,249,1963,14129,146017,1362961,17450227,200409465,
%T A012063 3064381137,41812246345,744091967643,11765081428705,239039270010305,
%U A012063 4298599985014945,98237724213189475,1980239469431883625
%N A012063 exp(arcsin(arcsin(x)))=1+x+1/2!*x^2+3/3!*x^3+9/4!*x^4+49/5!*x^5...
%R A012063
%O A012063 0,4
%K A012063 nonn
%A A012063 Patrick DEMICHEL (dml at hpfrcu03.france.hp.com)

so presumably arcsin is OK.

So we don't understand what is going on yet.

Maybe some seq fan can solve the puzzle.

Neil



More information about the SeqFan mailing list