Question on Sequence A046907 from Sloane's Database
David W. Wilson
wilson at cabletron.com
Thu Nov 4 19:32:56 CET 1999
"James A. Sellers" wrote:
>
> Dear Members of SeqFan,
>
> I have only been a member of this list for a few days, so forgive me if this is an inappropriate message to send!!
>
> I have a question on sequence A046907, which gives the values of n for which binomial(2n-1, n) is squarefree. The sequence is 1,2,3,4,6,9,10,12,36. I have now tried n=37 up to 1500 and have not found another term for the sequence. Is this sequence known to be finite?? That would be an interesting result, if it is known.
>
> Thanks for your time! I hope to hear from some of you soon.
>
> James
>
> ****************************************
> James A. Sellers
> Associate Professor, Mathematics
> Cedarville College
>
> sellersj at cedarville.edu
> http://www.cedarville.edu/dept/sm/jas_www.htm
This is one a broad set of problems which devolve to a unsolved general
problem. The general problem is:
Is the intersection of a given a-automatic and b-automatic set finite?
A k-automatic set is a set of integers whose base-k representations form
a regular language, that is, a language accepted by a finite automaton
or state machine.
If bases a and b are incompatible (do not have a common power), and if
an a-automatic set Sa and b-automatic set Sb are both of density 0
over the integers, it is believed that Sa intersect Sb is finite
(or something along this line).
The current problem is whether f(n) = (2n-1 choose n) is squarefree for
a finite number of n. It turns out that f(n) is divisible by 4 unless
n belongs to a 2-automatic set S2 (which happens to be the set of
numbers
whose binary representations contain at most two 1's). Similarly, f(n)
is divisibly by 9 unless n belongs to a 3-automatic set S3 (much harder
to describe). If f(n) is squarefree, therefore, n must belong to
S = S2 intersect S3. It is very probable that S is finite, but no
proof is known.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are other prize problems that devolve to the same general problem.
For instance:
Are there infinitely many positive integers n such that 2^n does not
contain a 7 in its decimal expansion?
The powers of 2 form a 2-automatic set S2. The numbers which do not
contain a 7 form a 10-automatic set S10. The problem devolves to
whether S2 intersect S10 is finite.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another prize problem:
Are there infinitely many positive integers n such that 2n choose n
is divisible by neither 3, 5, nor 7?
Here, the n with (2n choose n) indivisible by 3, 5, and 7, respectively,
form sets S3, S5, and S7 which are respectively 3-automatic,
5-automatic,
and 7-automatic. We are asking if S3 intersect S5 intersect S7 is
finite. In all likelyhood, an interesection of any two of these is
finite.
More information about the SeqFan
mailing list